Is it worth fixing? An honest way to decide
The short answer
Compare the repair against what the phone is worth repaired, not against a new one. If the repair costs less than half the working value and the phone still gets security updates, repair it. Software support, not condition, is usually what decides when a device is finished.
The comparison people get wrong
The instinct is to compare a repair against the price of a new phone, which makes every repair look expensive. The useful comparison is against what your phone is worth working, because that is the alternative you are actually choosing between.
A screen repair at a third of the phone's working value is straightforwardly worth doing. At more than the phone is worth, it is not, and no amount of attachment changes that arithmetic.
The second number is what a replacement genuinely costs you, which is not the headline price of a new flagship. A good used phone one generation back does the same job for a fraction, and that is the honest comparison.
The four questions that settle it
- Does it still get security updates?This decides more than condition does. A device no longer receiving them is one to plan around whatever state it is in.
- What is the total repair, not just this one?A screen on a phone whose battery is also finished is two repairs. Get both numbers and add them before deciding.
- What is the phone worth working?If the repair is under about half of that, it is usually worth doing. Well over it, and it usually is not.
- Is there anything on it you need?A phone with the only copy of somebody's photos is worth work that a well-backed-up phone is not, and people are usually clear which they have.
When repair is almost always right
- A battery on a phone under four years old. Cheapest repair, biggest difference
- A charging port, on most models. Small part, restores the device completely
- A screen on a phone you would otherwise buy again
- A console HDMI port, which costs a fraction of the console
- A laptop that shuts down under load, which is usually a clean and repaste rather than a failure
- Anything on a device still under manufacturer warranty, where the answer is to go to them first
When it usually is not
We would rather lose a repair than sell one that does not make sense, and this is where that gets tested. If the honest answer is that a device is finished, that is the answer you get, and it costs you nothing to hear it.
- Widespread liquid corrosion on an older phone, where a board can be technically repairable and still a bad idea
- A screen on a device that has stopped getting security updates
- Two or three expensive repairs at once on a phone near the end of its life
- A repair that costs more than the phone is worth working, unless the data is the point
- A laptop panel on a machine whose battery, keyboard and fans are all also finished
The case for repairing anyway
A repaired phone is a phone that does not get made. The manufacturing footprint of a handset dwarfs everything it will use in electricity over its life, so keeping one going another two years is the single most effective thing most people can do about it.
It is also usually the cheaper option by a distance, and the one that does not involve an afternoon moving accounts, apps and two-factor codes onto something new.
And a battery in a three-year-old phone frequently makes it feel like a different device, because the throttling that was making it slow stops the moment the cell can deliver peak current again.
Common questions.
Compare it against what your phone is worth working, not against a new one. Under about half that value, and still getting security updates, it is usually worth doing.
Yes, and it costs you nothing to hear it. The diagnostic is free and we would rather lose a repair than sell one that does not make sense.
Often, and noticeably. Phones throttle the processor when the cell can no longer deliver peak current, so replacing it removes the throttling as well as the short battery life.
Yes, and it is not close. Most of a phone's environmental cost is in making it, so keeping one going another two years beats almost anything you can do about how you use it.
Get both numbers and add them before deciding, which is why we test everything rather than the one thing you mentioned. Two repairs on a phone near the end of its life is usually where the answer becomes no.
Where this leads.
Something actually broken? Bring it in.
Free diagnostic, a firm price before any work, and a 360-day warranty on every completed repair.
Book a repair 24/7 · No fix, no fee · 360-day warranty · Free diagnostic